Robert Elsie

Texts and Documents of Albanian History

Baron Franz Nopcsa, ca. 1928.

1907

Baron Franz Nopcsa:

Murder Statistics in Northern Albania

Hungarian scholar Baron Nopcsa [see Document 1913 Nopcsa] travelled extensively in the northern Albanian mountains in the first decade of the twentieth century. Together with Edith Durham and Karl Steinmetz, he is considered to have been one of the most knowledgeable foreign scholars of northern Albanian culture in this period. What fascinated many foreign observers – then and now – was the seemingly senseless blood feuding among the northern tribes. A good portion of the male population in the mountains was decimated over the years in the vendettas. In this work, Nopcsa offers precise statistics on the numbers and percentages of deaths due to feuding. Now, a century since Nopcsa’s time, blood feuding once again plagues the northern Albanian mountains and it is quite possible that the murder statistics would be similar today. Among the victims are many male children, who for fear of falling victim to feuds, spend their childhood at home in the dark, and can never go outdoors or attend school. The insanity continues.

Since various views exist as to the percentage of murders among deaths occurring in northern Albania and even reputed scholars such as Dr Hassert give 25-75% for the male population, which would be a serious stain on the country’s reputation, I believe that the following information will be of general interest.

The figures given in the following tables derive from over half a year of travel in Catholic northern Albania in the company solely of natives. They are taken from the registries of deaths kept regularly in the various parishes that I consulted. I had originally intended to consult the death registries of all the Catholic parishes, but unforeseen circumstances forced me to abandon this endeavour. I was, however, able to gather data from 30 parishes, some of which were incomplete. The blanks in the following tables mean that there was no registry of deaths in the year and parish in question. The main reasons for this were vacancies or the advanced age of the priests concerned. In some parishes, for example in Orosh, the church registries have disappeared. Nonetheless, given that there are data for over a fifteen year period and for several dioceses, though fragmentary in some cases, I believe that general conclusions may be reached.

The rate of murder is much lower than generally thought. On average at the moment, not 25% or indeed 75%, but only 19% of the male population is murdered.

To appreciate this figure, one must take some factors into consideration. In Albania, one must differentiate between common or primary murders (robberies, hatred, disputes) and revenge or secondary murders (blood feuding).

It was impossible to ascertain from the registries how many of the murders given in the following tables belonged to the second category. However, since blood feuding is obligatory in northern Albania and is often the only legal means one can resort to, I would venture to say that almost half of the murders that take place in the country are acts of revenge. This is of great significance for an understanding of the Albanian character. An Albanian who kills his foe out of vengeance, who, as they say “ka mar gjak (has taken blood),” is guilty of far less a crime than his central European counterpart who has legal – albeit perhaps inadequate – means at his disposal to deal with defamation, but who prefers to challenge his opponent to a duel. In actual fact, blood feuding, duelling and hara-kiri are three equal means of dealing with the same problem.

In defence of the Albanians it must be noted that, as opposed to the situation in central Europe, killing women is virtually unknown. The only exception is when the wife is caught in flagranti in an act of adultery, in which case the avenger endeavours to shoot both the lovers with one bullet.

One explanation for the very high level of murders is that all the Albanians, who are very touchy and proud by nature, are armed. Murders committed during armed robbery are rare. Many murders are committed out of pure ignorance. A case in point is the statement of a friend of mine from Bugjon who said that he would much rather be murdered that grow ill and die a ‘straw death,’ i.e. of old age.

Further psychological aspects of murder and homicide are given in my sketch of Catholic northern Albania, published in Hungarian and in German, in the periodical of the Hungarian Geographical Society in Budapest.

About 24% of murders took place in the Diocese of Pulat, about 20% in the Abbacy of Mirdita, about 15% in the Diocese of Sappa, and about 13% in the Diocese of Lezha (Alessio). The highest percentage is 42.3 in the parish of Toplana of the Diocese of Pult, and the lowest percentage is 5.5% in the parish of Qafmal in the Abbacy of Mirdita.

Diocese of Pulat, Parish of Toplana* ca. 420 inhabitants

Year1890189118921893189418951896189718981899190019011902190319041905Total% of murders
Deaths1220120014215
Murders1010221111111
Total223034112532642.3

* “They are killing one another like in Toplana” is a common saying.

Abbey of Mirdita, Parish of Spaç, ca. 470 inhabitants

Year1890189118921893189418951896189718981899190019011902190319041905Total% of
murders
Deaths1413817
Murders301318
Total442692532.0

Abbey of Mirdita, Parish of Ndërfana (Nerfandina), ca. 450 inhabitants

Year1890189118921893189418951896189718981899190019011902190319041905Total% of
murders
Deaths613340157231751
Murders21050132131120
Total81439028936187128.1

Diocese of Pulat, Parish of Shala* ca. 2,800 inhabitants

Year1890189118921893189418951896189718981899190019011902190319041905Total% of
murders
Deaths1219262420232624121610169824269
Murders128118613124731254298
Total24272725282939361623132814122636726.7

* Up to 1899 including Shosh.

Diocese of Pulat, Parish of Nikaj, ca. 2,400 inhabitants

Year1890189118921893189418951896189718981899190019011902190319041905Total% of
murders
Deaths28482961210111010117910946263
Murders713478255945644992
Total35613313201216151915121514135535525.9

Abbey of Mirdita, Parish of Kaçinar, ca. 1,470 inhabitants

Year1890189118921893189418951896189718981899190019011902190319041905Total% of
murders
Deaths254041675251287927157
Murders6433574715133254
Total314474111499617910122921125.5

Diocese of Pulat, Parish of Shosh

Year1890189118921893189418951896189718981899190019011902190319041905Total% of
murders
Deaths911115511784493487106
Murders22023153030522636
Total1113117812121147986101314225.1

Abbey of Mirdita, Parish of Kashnjet, ca. 1,200 inhabitants

YearI only have the total figures for 1881-189119041905Total% of
murders
Deaths 81            1214107
Murders 32            1235
Total 113            131614224.5

Diocese of Pulat, Parish of Dushman

Year1890189118921893189418951896189718981899190019011902190319041905Total% of
murders
Deaths7162012108875453649121
Murders21001348304306338
Total91720121111121584966101215923.8

Abbey of Mirdita, Parish of Shëngjergj (Shënjerç), ca. 1,135 inhabitants

Year1890189118921893189418951896189718981899190019011902190319041905Total% of
murders
Deaths3666321624236354
Murders2302111110301016
Total596843273453737022.8

Abbey of Mirdita, Parish of Orosh

Year1890189118921893189418951896189718981899190019011902190319041905Total% of
murders
Deaths          10843833
Murders          230319
Total          12114694221.4

Abbey of Mirdita, Parish of Vig, ca. 480 inhabitants

Year1890189118921893189418951896189718981899190019011902190319041905Total% of
murders
Deaths             7815
Murders             044
Total             7121921.0

Diocese of Lezha (Alessio), Parish of Bërzana (Pedhana), ca. 288 inhabitants

Year1890189118921893189418951896189718981899190019011902190319041905Total% of
murders
Deaths4274781142661365
Murders212142211001017
Total63951110135366238220.7

Diocese of Sappa, Parish of Mazrek

Year1890189118921893189418951896189718981899190019011902190319041905Total% of
murders
Deaths2442502124531
Murders010021011118
Total254271223563920.5

Diocese of Shkodra, Parish of Shkrel

Year1890189118921893189418951896189718981899190019011902190319041905Total% of
murders
Deaths101017616161022168107366164
Murders34104132014256137
Total131418620171324169149812720118.4

Diocese of Sappa, Parish of Qelëza (Çelza), ca. 1,200-1,300 inhabitants

Year1890189118921893189418951896189718981899190019011902190319041905Total% of
murders
Deaths      66958510151175
Murders      14030130417
Total      71098861315149218.5

Diocese of Sappa, Parish of Koman

Year1890189118921893189418951896189718981899190019011902190319041905Total% of
murders
Deaths    9412121029
Murders    10003026
Total    1041242123517.1

Abbey of Mirdita, Parish of Korthpula, ca. 700 inhabitants

Year1890189118921893189418951896189718981899190019011902190319041905Total% of
murders
Deaths811343241515754
Murders02100202020211
Total81344344353596516.9

Diocese of Pulat, Parish of Shllak

Year1890189118921893189418951896189718981899190019011902190319041905Total% of
murders
Deaths11171658239  5311152102
Murders301000012*00102020
Total141717582321  531217212216.4

* As a result of an exchange of words on Easter Sunday right at the church door.

Diocese of Lezha (Alessio), Parish of Bulgër, ca. 700 inhabitants

Year1890189118921893189418951896189718981899190019011902190319041905Total% of
murders
Deaths131212471214377855121122
Murders02640101101220121
Total13141887131448797712214314.6

Diocese of Lezha (Alessio), Parish of Manatia, ca. 450 inhabitants

Year1890189118921893189418951896189718981899190019011902190319041905Total% of
murders
Deaths 8353794333553
Murders 002010103018
Total 837389536366113.1

Diocese of Lezha (Alessio), Parish of Rrëshen, ca. 1,000 inhabitants

Year1890189118921893189418951896189718981899190019011902190319041905Total% of
murders
Deaths           9154213786
Murders           3147217
Total           12168283910313.0

Diocese of Lezha (Alessio), Parish of Kallmet

Year1890189118921893189418951896189718981899190019011902190319041905Total% of
murders
Deaths66837853242137873
Murders04011100000002211
Total610848953242139108413.0

Abbey of Mirdita, Parish of Blinisht, ca. 1,000 inhabitants

Year1890189118921893189418951896189718981899190019011902190319041905Total% of
murders
Deaths4  17  1344162261
Murders1  4*1101029
Total5  21  145426247012.8

* One man in the village was sentenced to death and shot by all the villagers together.

Abbey of Mirdita, Parish of Munella, ca. 600 inhabitants

Year1890189118921893189418951896189718981899190019011902190319041905Total% of
murders
Deaths             36716
Murders             1102
Total             4771811.1

Diocese of Lezha (Alessio), Parish of Vela (Velia)

Year1890189118921893189418951896189718981899190019011902190319041905Total% of
murders
Deaths1011144251097671010694124
Murders130103010101000112
Total111414528101077711106951368.8

Diocese of Lezha (Alessio), Parish of Kryezez, ca. 700 inhabitants

Year1890189118921893189418951896189718981899190019011902190319041905Total% of
murders
Deaths255756553245
Murders10010000114
Total3558565543498.1

Diocese of Pulat, Parish of Kir

Year1890189118921893189418951896189718981899190019011902190319041905Total% of
murders
Deaths88743353512412257
Murders1200001000100005
Total9107433635134122628.0

Diocese of Sappa, Parish of Nënshat, ca. 700 inhabitants

Year1890189118921893189418951896189718981899190019011902190319041905Total% of
murders
Deaths101171092676877918118
Murders100012300000018
Total11117101049768779191266.3

Abbey of Mirdita, Parish of Qafmal

Year1890189118921893189418951896189718981899190019011902190319041905Total% of
murders
Deaths          6321517
Murders          000011
Total          63216185.5

[Franz Baron Nopcsa: Beitrag zur Statistik der Morde in Nordalbanien. in: Mitteilungen der kais. königl. Geographischen Gesellschaft in Wien, Vienna, 50, 8 (1907), p. 429-437. Translated from the German by Robert Elsie.]